Anyway, when I was in Chicago, I made my first trip to Ulta!
There, I saw three of the four colours: Juicy Papaya, Sorbet, and Wild Watermelon. I didn't see Pink Lemonade.
I ended up selecting Juicy Papaya. This sort of pink coral is my thing, haha.
|L: heavy swatch; R: single swipe|
smooth; buttery lip balm
light coral pink
I really like it. If you have pigmented lips, like me, then the colour payoff obviously isn't as pink as swatched above. On my mauve pink lips, the colour is definitely visible, but is more of a medium coral orange. Amy's (theprettyvain) swatch of Juicy Papaya is actually pretty true to how it looks on my lips (appears a smidge more pink on me).
Apparently, these colours are not limited edition colours, and will be added to permanent line. So, no rush... though, I'm sure they'll sell quickly.